Duffy slams sports prediction market regulation as executives spar on legal status

4th November, 2026

Radi Khasawneh
Terry Duffy

Terry Duffy, chairman and chief executive of CME Group has said that ongoing legal disputes about the oversight of sports prediction trading are likely to go against the venues that offer them.

In a barnstorming armchair interview at the FIA Expo event in Chicago on Wednesday, Duffy criticised the approach of both the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and venues like Kalshi who offer the contracts under the current regime.

“I believe that predictions on sports are nothing more than gambling,” Duffy said. “They are in violation of Core Principle 3 of the Commodity Exchange Act – which covers markets susceptible to manipulation.

“That concerns me because I spent a good part of my career… trying to build a regulatory framework that makes sense for everybody that trades in it around the world and to be the envy of financial markets. We are going the other way by allowing markets to go forward that are susceptible to manipulation.”

He also referenced rival Kalshi – a CFTC regulated venue that specialises in prediction markets.

“For Kalshi, 90% of their prediction markets are based on sports, and it is going to go to the Supreme Court, I think they are going to lose horribly,” he added. “This is nothing more than gambling. Now I did hear a comment from the lady from Kalshi yesterday about how they should have a transaction tax to fund this particular area which just goes to show that some people don’t understand math very well that went to MIT.

“When you look at math its simple, if you are going to fund a tax on predictions at State level, there is a tax on online gaming companies and on the participants. So its double taxation. With a transaction tax you would have to charge an extraordinary amount, because there is not enough transactions to add up to the billions that these online platforms and participants pay.”

Duffy was referring to comments by Luana Lopes Lara, co-founder and chief operating Officer of Kalshi at the event on a separate panel on Tuesday, where she said that the venue would be open to agreeing to pay some form of tax to States in the event that a decision goes against them.

“At this point Kalshi is a very diversified business already, and by the time the Supreme Court actually looks at this it will be even more so…” Lara said at the event on Tuesday. “We crossed $1 billion in revenue outside of sports, which is way bigger than sports was seven or eight months ago. It shows how fast our growth is across the board, it is really not just sports. Even if something goes wrong with the Supreme Court – which we don’t think will happen – it is not a question of just going back to the States. There is uncertainty over what it would actually mean and how it would actually work, but we always say that a diversified business is a better business.”

Duffy is set to be replaced in March by Lynne Fitzpatrick, president and chief financial officer of CME.

“I think the Supreme Court ultimately will decide where this ends up,” Fitzpatrick said on the same panel on Tuesday. “One of the things that is important as we think about the various markets that we all run, is looking at the contracts that we are listing and bringing to market and seeing if they actually meet the regulatory requirements.

“So things like not being readily susceptible to manipulation, or do they provide economic benefit to the users. If we look at the brand and reputation we have built as an industry, I want to make sure that we are thinking about that as we move into these new spaces and not chipping away at that reputation with things that maybe are a little less clearly markets versus gambling. With mention markets... it becomes harder to make some of our arguments about the economic benefits of those contracts.”

In Europe, the current rules only allow sports contracts to be offered to retail, but subject to gambling regulations. That makes it a much less attractive proposition according to Robbert Booij, chief executive officer of Eurex on the Tuesday panel.

“ESMA has said that when a contract refers to a financial underlying, it is considered a binary option, and that is not allowed to be offered to retail investors unless it concerns sports,” Booij said. “In that case you are allowed to offer it to end investors but then the gambling rules apply, and that is not something our exchange is interested in – we do not see that as the right thing going forward.

“The right contracts from an institutional perspective would be CPI data for example, or central bank rates decisions as potential underlying for an event contract. That is something we are working on, but so far the institutional interest for event contracts like that is somewhat limited as well.”

Duffy also predicted that CFTC chair Michael Selig will be in for a rocky period after the US midterm elections, which have seen sweeping democratic gains across both houses of Congress.

“I think he’s got troubles,” Duffy said. “You cannot have an agency that has one Commissioner and unilaterally make all these decisions, and publicly state that he can do it on his own and its more efficient that way.

“The agency works better – anybody in Washington knows – that you work better with a full complement of Commissioners. You don’t work well with a dictator. So I wouldn’t want to be him over the next couple of months, I think he’s got a lot of questions to answer.”

Duffy added that he intends to continue advocating for sound market regulations in the US capital going forward.

“I’m going to be very aggressive in Washington like I always have been, and I think after last night Washington is going to be a very interesting place for a lot of people. I am going to be part of that,” he added.

Related topics

Loading...